Arch Manning Snubs Uncles Eli and Peyton, Names Tom Brady as Greatest QB of All Time

AUSTIN, TX – The Manning family is synonymous with quarterback greatness, but young star Arch Manning has stirred up debate by choosing Tom Brady as the greatest quarterback of all time—over his legendary uncles, Eli and Peyton Manning.

A Surprising Pick from the Next-Generation Manning

In a recent interview, the Texas Longhorns quarterback was asked to name his choice for the greatest quarterback ever. Instead of keeping it in the family, Arch bypassed both Eli and Peyton and gave the crown to seven-time Super Bowl champion Tom Brady.

“I have to go with Tom Brady,” Arch reportedly said. “What he did over his career—winning, leadership, longevity—it’s hard to argue against him.”

While the choice makes sense from a statistical and championship standpoint, it still comes as a surprise given Arch’s deep football roots. His grandfather, Archie Manning, was a respected NFL quarterback, and his uncles, Peyton and Eli, are both Super Bowl-winning legends in their own right.

A Lighthearted Jab at Family?

Eli and Peyton Manning, known for their playful personalities, are likely to have some fun with Arch’s pick. Both have been major influences in his development, helping guide him through the recruiting process and mentoring him as he follows in their footsteps.

Peyton, a two-time Super Bowl champion and five-time MVP, is often mentioned in the GOAT conversation. Eli, who famously defeated Brady’s Patriots twice in the Super Bowl, has always embraced the underdog role.

While some fans see Arch’s statement as a slight toward family, others believe it’s simply an honest assessment of football history.

Respect for the GOAT

Tom Brady’s seven Super Bowl rings, three MVP awards, and 23-year career make him an undeniable force in the GOAT debate. Even members of the Manning family—despite their history with Brady on the field—have acknowledged his greatness.

Arch’s pick doesn’t diminish his admiration for his uncles, but it does add an interesting twist to the long-running Manning vs. Brady debate. With Arch set to make his own mark on the game at Texas and beyond, the football world will be watching to see if he can eventually join the conversation as one of the greats himself.